Watchmen: The Black Freighter & Under the Hood
Movie Running Time: 66 minutes
My Running Time: 60 minutes
Elliptical Revolutions: 3294
Calories Burned: 778
My Mass: 190lbs, 86.2kg (-0.0lbs, -0.0kg)
The Black Freighter and Under the Hood both existed as supplements to the main story in the original graphic novel of Watchmen. The Black Freighter was a story from a pirate comic being read by a secondary character. Under the Hood was published as excerpts from the autobiography of Hollis Mason, the first Nite Owl, and was presented often in single spaced text at the end of an issue. To adapt these two stories into a film version of Watchmen is difficult at best, and director Zack Snyder took his best shot at both.
The Black Freighter was originally supposed to be a live action 300-esque production, complete with Gerard Butler playing the lead role. Due to the projected $20 million that would have been needed to make that portion, it became an animated film, though it retained Gerard Butler as a voice actor for the lead role. The story of the Black Freighter is meant to mirror the moral dilemma proposed by Adrian Veidt in his attempt to scare the world into peace. In the Black Freighter, the lead character struggles to get home and save Davidstown after his ship is sunk by the infamous freighter. Instead he turns himself into a murderous monster when he accidently kills his wife and two other residents, believing them to be crew members from the Black Freighter. In the end he is welcomed into the rotting arms of the freighter’s hideous crew.
I think if inserted into the Director’s Cut of Watchmen these animated portions will be too jarring. The production quality of the animation is subpar for Warner Brother’s animated material, almost looking as poor as the Motion Comic chapter included with this release. If it had been live action, I think the comparison would have been more appropriate, between the “real” comic book world that the Watchmen exist in, and the “fake” comic book world of The Black Freighter.
Under the Hood presented an even more difficult adaptation. Other than directly filming the events described in the text of the autobiography there really isn’t any other way to convey the information. The solution arrived at was to make Under the Hood an interview television special with Hollis Mason, where the host discusses the actual book with him, and some other interviewees. The most enjoyable part of this production is seeing the vintage footage of the original Minutemen, whether its in their golden years of retirement, or in old newsreel or promotional material. It highlights the attention to detail Snyder and the rest of his crew had, and gives a bit more screen time to characters that were more fleshed out in the graphic novel.
If you plan on buying these films in any form, skip the Blu-ray edition. The production values of both films do no warrant High Definition in any form, and the cost is far too extreme for 66 minute runtime of the two films together. I recommend either renting this movie, or if you have the know how, buying it for only $4.99 on the US iTunes store as a digital version.
Tags: health, Movie Review, Running, Superheroes, Watchmen